Physics professor Alvin Kanofsky, 77, has not yet decided if he will appeal to a higher court.
A Lehigh University professor was fined about $30,000 and sentenced to five days in jail for allowing his once-prominent South Bethlehem property to fall into such disrepair it's in danger of collapsing.
Alvin Kanofsky has owned the former Goodman Furniture building at 30 E. Third St. for 30 years. The city has a thick code violation file on Kanofsky and has been aggressively trying to get the blighted property cleaned up.
In April, District Judge Nancy Matos Gonzalez found Kanofsky guilty of 17 code violations, related to the deterioration of the building's roof and his lack of a valid certificate of occupancy. She fined him $30,700 and sentenced him to 20 days in Northampton County Prison, Bethlehem assistant city solicitor Matthew Deschsler said.
Kanofsky appealed her decision and on Wednesday morning a hearing was held in Northampton County Court before Senior Judge Leonard Zito.
After a lengthy hearing -- Kanofsky represented himself -- Zito upheld the guilty convictions, reimposed the fines and ordered the 77-year-old to report to county jail Monday to serve a five-day sentence.
Kanofsky can appeal the decision to Pennsylvania Superior Court.
"I'll have to consider things," the physics professor said following the hearing.
20 places Bethlehem wants cleaned up now
In October 2015, Kanofksy reached an agreement with the city that he would repair the roof and crumbling stucco facade within six months. Kanofsky still has not performed the repairs, testified Craig Hynes, the city's chief building inspector.
In February of this year, Hynes repeatedly cited Kanofsky for the violations on consecutive days. The citations began two years after he was notified of the original violations, he said.
"Eventually, if nothing is done this building will collapse," Hynes said.
Kanofsky repeatedly said that the masonry and roof work cannot be performed during the winter.
Deschsler noted that Kanofsky was advised of the need for those repairs a long time ago.
"There are giant holes in the roof," Deschler said.
He's now had the spring, summer and fall of 2015 and this spring and summer to take action, but he has not, Deschler said.
"I feel I am not responsible for the collapse of the roof," Kanofsky said.
"I was conscientiously pursuing repairs to the building," he later added.
Zito pointed out the issue wasn't Kanofsky's lack of effort to get quotes to repair the building.
"You are being cited for the lack of accomplishment," Zito said.
Kanofksy once operated a flea market out of the building. It is now used for storage -- a use that the city requires a valid certificate of occupancy for -- and the building has no electric or water service.
"The property is used to store massive amounts of stuff," Deschler said.
So much water is pouring through the roof, Hynes testified, that when he entered the property in 2007 there were 30 trash cans set up to collect water and two small pumps to pump water into a drain following storms.
Bethlehem police Lt. Benjamin Hackett testified at a hearing for separate violations that when he entered the building in March 2015 the same set-up remained, Deschler said.
The city has closed the adjacent sidewalk and a parking lot because a portion of the stucco facade has buckled, he said.
"It's defying gravity at this point," Hynes said.
Kanofsky tried to argue that when the city's blighted property review committee in 2008 took his property off the blight list, that amounted to a valid certificate of occupancy. He said he was unable to find the letter for his earlier hearing.
"The Lord above made this available to me," Kanofsky sad.
Hynes disagreed, saying he is the only person who can issue such a certificate.
Deschler questioned how it matters what the property looked like in 2008. What matters is its current state, he said.
"It's gonna kill someone someday," Deschler said.
In May, Judge Michael Koury upheld Kanofsky's code violation citations that were issued after Hackett entered the building in March 2015.
There was some confusion over how much Kanofsky should be fined for the most recent citations for which he was found guilty.
Zito rattled off fines and court costs for all 17 convictions and Deschler then noted the ordinance caps fines at $1,000. Zito said he was just imposing the same fines laid out in the district court transcript, which he believes include court costs Kanofsky is also responsible for.
Deschler said he believed the fines should total $30,700, which Zito ordered would be reconciled by the court following the hearing.
Sara K. Satullo may be reached at ssatullo@njadvancemedia.com. Follow her on Twitter @sarasatullo and Facebook. Find lehighvalleylive.com on Facebook.